
Project Summary Archives
Spring 2006 Project Summaries
Texas
Components of Fishing Mortality for Largemouth Bass at Sam Rayburn
Reservoir with Implications for Alternative Length Limits
Contact: Todd Driscoll, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department,
Rt 2 Box 535, Jasper, TX 75951, todd.driscoll@tpwd.state.tx.us
The largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides fishery at Sam Rayburn Reservoir is managed with a 356-mm minimum length limit (MLL). In 2001, 47% of anglers favored more restrictive largemouth bass length limits, assuming a resulting increase of fish > 457 mm. In 2003, 6,021 largemouth bass > 315 mm were tagged to estimate annual fishing mortality and explore potential benefits of more restrictive length limits via population modeling. Due to popularity of tournament angling (52% of anglers participate and annual events exceed 300) and high voluntary release rate (42%) at Sam Rayburn Reservoir, our fishing mortality estimate included non-tournament harvest, tournament mortality, and catch-and-release mortality. Catch and harvest of tagged fish by tournament and non-tournament anglers was estimated via creel sampling to avoid non-reporting uncertainty, adjusted for recruitment and tag loss, and expanded to estimate total annual tagged fish catch and harvest. Tournament and catch-and-release mortality was simulated at rates of 10, 30, and 50% and 5, 10, and 15%, respectively. Population loss from non-tournament harvest was 6 - 14% and tournament and catch-and-release mortality simulations both resulted in losses of 1 – 6%. Our estimated range of total fishing mortality was 7 – 24%. Compared to the current 356-mm MLL, population modeling indicates 406-mm and 457-mm MLLs provide minimal increases of fish reaching 457 mm (1 – 4% and 3 – 11%, respectively). A more restrictive MLL would reduce tournament catch available for weigh-in and provide little benefit compared to the current regulation.
Impact of Tournaments on the Largemouth Bass Population at Sam
Rayburn Reservoir, Texas
Contact: Todd Driscoll, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, Rt
2 Box 535, Jasper, TX 75951, todd.driscoll@tpwd.state.tx.us
Concerns regarding tournament-related impacts on black bass Micropterus spp. have prevailed during the last 40 years. However, few studies have empirically estimated effects of tournaments on black bass populations. An estimated 52% of Sam Rayburn Reservoir anglers participate in tournaments and the annual number of events likely exceeds 300. In 2003, we tagged and released 6,021 largemouth bass M. salmoides to estimate the annual proportion of the population caught and retained by tournament anglers. Tag returns were obtained via creel sampling to avoid non-reporting uncertainty, adjusted for recruitment and tag loss, and expanded to estimate total annual tagged fish catch and harvest. We conducted simulations to evaluate impacts of tournament mortality using rates of 10, 30, and 50% and compared those estimates to non-tournament harvest and catch-and-release mortality (simulated at 5, 10, and 15%) to assess specific contributions to annual angling and total mortality. From 3,447 angler interviews, creel clerks identified 40 tagged fish caught by anglers during the interview day (27 immediately released, 6 harvested by non-tournament anglers, and 7 retained by tournament anglers). Expansion of tag returns resulted in 1,620 fish immediately released (27% of tagged population), 372 harvested by non-tournament anglers (6% of tagged population), and 274 retained by tournament anglers (5% of tagged population). Tournament and catch-and-release mortality each comprised a total of 1 - 6% of the population losses across all simulations. Tournament mortality comprised 6 - 28% of total angling mortality, whereas catch-and-release mortality was 10 - 31%. Tournament mortality contributed 1 - 16% of total annual mortality, compared to 2 - 17% for catch-and-release mortality and 16 - 38% for non-tournament harvest. We conclude that tournament-related impacts on the largemouth bass population at Sam Rayburn Reservoir were low.
Lake Fork Reservoir is an established trophy largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides fishery and has been managed under a protective slot limit since 1989. Largemouth bass 16 to 24 inches in length must be released, and only one fish over 24 inches may be kept. The fact that Lake Fork has produced 34 of the 50 biggest largemouth bass in Texas draws anglers from a broad geographic area and the trophy fishery provides a significant source of revenue for the local economy. Despite intensive sampling using standard procedures, fisheries managers in Texas have very little information on catches of trophy bass. We sought to characterize the Lake Fork trophy bass fishery using voluntary reporting of trophy fish catches. Initiated in March 2003, this ongoing survey targets bass weighing ≥ 7 lbs and/or measuring ≥ 24 inches.
Initially developed to provide recreational anglers with information on trophy bass catches, and to promote the bass fishery on Lake Fork, the trophy bass survey contains valuable information for managers. As of February 2006, we obtained information on over 5,200 trophy largemouth bass. Of the anglers reporting trophy catches, 61.7% were Texas residents. Residents of other states reporting trophy catches on Lake Fork include Oklahoma (6.0%), Missouri (5.9%), Louisiana (5.3%), and Arkansas (4.4%). Most trophy catches were reported during spring (March-May; 57.2%), followed by summer (June-August; 20.4%), winter (December-February; 12.6%), and fall (September-November; 9.8%).
We examined whether mean weight and body condition (Wr) varied as a function of year, season, moon phase, or time of day when the fish was caught. Preliminary analyses suggest mean weight and body condition of trophy bass caught during winter (December – February) were significantly higher than during all other seasons, while trophy bass mean weight and body condition during summer (June – August) were significantly lower than during all other seasons. Additionally, more trophy bass were caught per day during full moon periods than other moon phases, but this was only significant during fall months.
The number of trophy bass reported during a sampling quarter was positively correlated with directed angler effort as estimated by access creel surveys; however, the number of trophy bass caught per hour of effort was higher during the winter than during other seasons. Using trophy bass survey data in conjunction with angler access creel surveys, we conclude that the slot limit on Lake Fork is effectively sustaining the trophy bass fishery.
We are monitoring native plant introductions on Lake LBJ in Central Texas. Eight species of native plants were introduced in 2000 at 6 sites on the reservoir to improve habitat for cover seeking species. The reservoir shoreline is highly developed and about 80% is bulkheaded. Introduced plants were protected by wire mesh cages and shoreline fences. In 2002 two species of plants already present on the reservoir (water willow and spatterdock) prior to the introductions were transplanted into a new site and in-between cages at several old sites. Minimal spread for all species outside the cages has been observed in five years, although the indigenous transplants (water willow and spatterdock) have increased significantly inside a large shoreline fence area. Transplants used outside cages have survived, but have not increased as greatly as those put inside the shoreline fence.
Three hundred and seventy eight fish attractors made of plastic piping were introduced at 15 sites in Canyon Reservoir in Central Texas in January 2005. The purpose of the introductions was to improve angler catch rates. The attractors resemble large bushes and the plastic is reported to have a life of 20 years. Cedar trees were used at three additional sites. All attractors were placed in 20-25 feet of water and site locations were marked with GPS and distributed to the public as requested. In summer 2005 sites with water clarity adequate for observing fish were scuba dived. No fish were observed on the plastic attractors, while many largemouth bass and sunfish were observed in the cedar tree attractors. In January 2006 cedar trees were added to some sites which previously had plastic attractors only. Sites (cedar only, plastic only and combination) will be compared again in summer 2006.
A volunteer trophy bass reporting project has been in place at Fayette County Reservoir in Central Texas since October 2004. The purpose of the project is to supplement electrofishing data on largemouth bass greater than 21 inches in length. This reservoir has a 14-24 inch slot length limit and electrofishing catches of bass greater than 21 inches have historically been low since the upper end of the slot limit increased from 21 to 24 inches in 1995. Approximately 200 angler catches of bass greater than 21 inches have been voluntarily reported. A concurrent traditional creel survey will be used to compare size distributions of the catch.
Quarterly aquatic vegetation monitoring has been occurring on Lake Austin in Central Texas since May of 2003 to document the effects of grass carp introductions and a reservoir drawdown. These control efforts were made in response to concerns about hydrilla coverage. In May 2002 hydrilla covered 320 acres of this 1,599 acre highly developed urban reservoir. Since February 2003 8,125 grass carp have been introduced and drawdowns have occurred each winter except 2005/06. Hydrilla coverage has been reduced to less than 10 acres. Other aquatic plants, dominated by eurasion water milfoil, still cover approximately 10 percent of the reservoir surface. Aquatic plant coverage is highest in the upper end of the reservoir where cold water temperatures from hypolimnetic releases may be decreasing grass carp feeding rates. Annual electrofishing surveys are being conducted to document changes in the reservoirs largemouth bass population.
Comparison of Guided and Unguided Fishing Trips from Two Texas
Reservoirs
Contact: John H. Moczygemba, Lake Texoma Fisheries Station, Texas
Parks and Wildlife Department, P.O. 1446, Pottsboro, TX 75076,
john.moczygemba@tpwd.state.tx.us
We compared angling metrics and bait use during guided and unguided fishing trips on 16 Texas freshwater reservoirs from March 1997 to February 2000. Only Lakes Texoma and Fork had sufficient creel interviews of guided parties to analyze the desired differences between guided and unguided trips. At Lake Texoma, guided trips accounted for 60% of the directed effort for striped bass Morone saxatilis. Forty-six percent of the guided anglers used live bait; 77% of the striped bass harvested were taken during guided fishing trips. On Lake Fork, largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides anglers with or without guides had equal catch rates (largemouth bass per hour), but unguided anglers caught 81% of the largemouth bass. Unguided fishing trips accounted for 80% of the angling hours. Largemouth bass harvest was very low. Ninety-four percent of largemouth bass anglers used artificial lures; they caught almost 95% of the largemouth bass. We conclude striped bass anglers are more apt to employ a guide, use live bait, spend more time fishing, and guided anglers catch and harvest more fish than unguided anglers. Further, largemouth bass anglers are less likely to employ a guide and most will use artificial lures and release their catch. Guided and unguided anglers spend the same amount of time fishing per trip and catch equal number of largemouth bass per hour.
Genetic evaluation of striped bass in Lake Texoma, Texas and Oklahoma. By Bruce Hysmith, Loraine Fries, Jamie Dixson, John Moczygemba, and Dijar Lutz-Carillo is nearing completion and will be submitted for publication in the SEAFWA this year. Objectives of the study were 1) resolve population structure of striped bass in Lake Texoma; are striped bass in the Red River arm genetically different from striped bass in the Washita River arm; 2) determine if striped bass were inbreeding; and 3) evaluate the effect of stocking events over time. To answer these questions scale tissue samples from 44 striped bass collected in 1978 we analyzed, fin-clips collected from 264 striped bass at various sites in the reservoir from 1997 through 2001 were analyzed as follows: genomic DNA was isolated and analyzed at the A. E. Wood Laboratory and alleles amplified at microsatellite loci were fluorescently tagged and separated on 6.5% polyacrylamide gels for identification. In summary: 1) no population substructure was detected, no genetic difference between Red River and Washita River striped bass, 2) Texoma striped bass exhibited no significant evidence of recent inbreeding, and 3) genetic diversity has actually increased probably through stocking events over time.
Completed crappie telemetry project designed to determine if learning more about crappie locations could improve our ability to select trap netting sites. We learned that knowing crappie locations did not improve trap net catch rates primarily because crappie often selected habitat variables (water depth, distance from shore, bank slope) where trap nets did not fish effectively. We are beginning a new project to investigate alternative net designs and deployment strategies to better sample these fish.
Short-term post stocking mortality of red drum,
Sciaenops ocellatus, and effects of acclimation time and stocking
season on survivorship
Contact: Michael S. Baird, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department,
8684 LaVillage Avenue, Waco, TX 76712, Michael.Baird@tpwd.state.tx.us
Texas Parks and Wildlife Department (TPWD), Inland and Coastal Fisheries Divisions, have maintained a stocking program for the marine red drum, Sciaenops ocellatus, in six freshwater power plant reservoirs since the early 1980s. Inland Fisheries Management crews have reported low catch rates during standardized gill netting surveys, and increased gill netting efforts yield few additional red drum. One possibility for the consistently low catch rates observed is low densities of adult fish, attributed to severe post stocking mortality. We analyzed the effects of acclimation time (2.5 h vs. 5.0 h) and stocking season (spring vs. fall) on post stocking survivorship of red drum fingerlings in two power plant reservoirs using current TPWD rearing and hauling procedures. Calaveras and Tradinghouse Creek reservoirs were similar in size, depth and physicochemical make-up, except Calaveras maintained salinities twice that of Tradinghouse Creek (0.8 and 0.4 ppt respectively). Mean spring and fall temperatures recorded during the study were 31.3 and 16.6ºC for Tradinghouse Creek and 32.6 and 19.7ºC for Calaveras. Overall, only 960 of 9600 fingerlings tested survived the 72 h experiment. Slow-acclimated fingerlings had higher survivorship than fast-acclimated fingerlings regardless of reservoir or season. Fall-stocked fingerlings had higher survivorship than spring-stocked fingerlings regardless of acclimation time or reservoir. Calaveras stockings were four times more successful than Tradinghouse Creek stockings. Our results show red drum stockings in freshwater power plant reservoirs should benefit from fall stockings and by acclimating fingerlings for at least five h prior to release.
An evaluation of growth of selectively bred largemouth
bass in six Texas reservoirs
Contact: Michael S. Baird, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department,
8684 LaVillage Avenue, Waco, TX 76712, Michael.Baird@tpwd.state.tx.us
Florida largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides floridanus were introduced to Texas in 1972 to develop a fast growing fish that would reach trophy size. The introduction of the Florida strain was evident by 1980, when the 37-year old Texas state record was broken by a Florida largemouth bass. All subsequent records have been identified as pure Florida largemouth bass or having some Florida bass genetic influence (D. Campbell, TPWD, personal communication). Texas Parks and Wildlife Department established the Budweiser ShareLunker program (originally called Operation Share a Lone Star Lunker) in 1986, to selectively breed and stock largemouth bass that would have the genetic potential to grow larger and faster than Florida largemouth bass. Between 1974 and 1993 the number of Texas reservoirs producing trophy largemouth bass increased from 2 to 35. By the early 1990s, the number and size of fish donated to the program had peaked. Today, entries have diminished in overall size of fish caught since 1992 and in numbers of fish donated since 1995 (A. Forshage, TPWD, personal communication). Additionally, the 18.18-pound state record has not been broken since 1992. Our understanding of fish genetics and rearing has improved tremendously since the inception of the Florida strain program, however our record books and programs have stopped reflecting improvements to the fishery. The aim of this study is to determine whether largemouth bass produced by the selective breeding program grow significantly faster and larger than fish from existing stocks. Our study will compare growth (i.e., mean weight at age- 4) of two cohorts of largemouth bass in six study reservoirs. The cohorts are defined as wild offspring (WOS), spawned from natural residents of the 6 selected study reservoirs, and lunker offspring (LOS), which are selectively bred from ShareLunker fish. Significant differences in growth of LOS over WOS, if validated, may facilitate TPWD’s largemouth bass selective breeding program for the improvement of trophy fisheries in the future.